Investing a fixed amount every month on the PSX: what 13 years of KSE-100 data show
By the Capitalist research team, from Capitalist's own market data. Published 9 November 2026.
Putting the same amount into the market every month, whatever the price, is how many salaried people invest. Fund houses call it a systematic investment plan (SIP). We tested it on the KSE-100 with Rs10,000 at the start of every month from January 2013 to November 2026.
That is 167 instalments, Rs1,670,000 in total. On 6 November 2026 they were worth about Rs7,003,000, a little over four times what went in. As a yearly rate on money that went in gradually, that is 18.9%.
The headline number hides the part that tests people's patience, so it is worth looking at the path year by year.
Ten slow years, then three fast ones
| End of | Paid in so far | Worth | Gain on what was paid |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2013 | Rs120,000 | Rs149,600 | +25% |
| 2014 | Rs240,000 | Rs325,100 | +35% |
| 2015 | Rs360,000 | Rs449,800 | +25% |
| 2016 | Rs480,000 | Rs812,100 | +69% |
| 2017 | Rs600,000 | Rs794,600 | +32% |
| 2018 | Rs720,000 | Rs832,500 | +16% |
| 2019 | Rs840,000 | Rs1,052,100 | +25% |
| 2020 | Rs960,000 | Rs1,269,500 | +32% |
| 2021 | Rs1,080,000 | Rs1,410,200 | +31% |
| 2022 | Rs1,200,000 | Rs1,391,000 | +16% |
| 2023 | Rs1,320,000 | Rs2,317,400 | +76% |
| 2024 | Rs1,440,000 | Rs4,456,600 | +209% |
| 2025 | Rs1,560,000 | Rs6,897,200 | +342% |
After ten years of steady saving, at the end of 2022, the account was only 16% above what had gone into it. As a yearly rate that is 2.9%, below what bank savings accounts typically paid in those years. Most of the final result came in the three years from 2023 to 2025, when the KSE-100 rose 54.5%, 84.3% and 51.2%.
Someone who gave up in 2022 would have stopped just before the period that made the plan worthwhile. That is the main lesson in the table, and it concerns the saver's patience.
How often monthly investing ended below what was paid in
A single 13-year run is one story. To see a wider range, we tested every start month in the data, each with the same Rs10,000 a month, for three lengths of plan:
| Plan length | Plans tested | Ended below what was paid in | Worst result | Best result |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 year | 155 | 34% | −20.8% (started Sep 2018) | +56.4% (started Jan 2024) |
| 3 years | 131 | 21% | −28.0% (started Sep 2016) | +164.6% (started Oct 2022) |
| 5 years | 107 | 13% | −23.5% (started Apr 2015) | +222.1% (started Feb 2021) |
Each plan is valued at the start of the month after its last instalment.
Longer plans failed less often, but a five-year plan still ended in a loss about one time in eight. The worst five-year plans all ran into the long fall from 2017 to 2020 described in KSE-100 crashes and recoveries.
Monthly or all at once
If you already have a sum to invest, is it better to put it in at once or spread it over months? We compared the two over the same windows: the full amount invested on the first day, against the same amount spread evenly.
Investing all at once did better in about three out of four cases: 67% of one-year windows, 75% of three-year windows and 78% of five-year windows. That follows from the data. The KSE-100 rose in most periods, so money that went in earlier had longer to grow.
Spreading out helped in the periods that started near a high. It lowered the worst outcomes, and for many people that is worth the lower average. Rs10,000 a month started in June 2017, just after the old high, was back above the total paid in by 30 July 2020. A single sum invested on 1 June 2017 took until 7 June 2021 to get back to where it started.
For most savers the question does not arise, because the money arrives monthly with the salary. Investing it as it comes is the practical choice. The comparison matters mainly for a bonus, an inheritance or the sale of a property.
Doing it in practice
You cannot buy the KSE-100 itself. The usual routes are:
- An equity mutual fund or index fund. Most fund houses in Pakistan let you set up a monthly plan, and some accept small amounts. Fees (the expense ratio and any sales load) come out of returns every year. Compare funds on the funds pages.
- An exchange-traded fund on the PSX, bought through a broker each month. Trading costs are charged on each purchase, so very small monthly amounts lose a larger share to fixed charges. The handbook page on brokerage and trading costs explains them.
- Shares of individual companies, which adds the risk that a few holdings do much worse than the index.
For a Shariah-compliant plan, the benchmark is usually the KMI-30 instead; the KMI-30 compared with the KSE-100 shows how the two differed.
To project your own plan, use the SIP calculator. Try a lower yearly return than the 18.9% above as well. That figure comes from one strong period and is no forecast.
What the test leaves out
- Costs and taxes. A real fund charges fees, and tax applies to dividends and capital gains. The figures here are before both.
- The index is not a fund. The KSE-100 is a total return index, with cash dividends added back, as calculated by PSX. A fund tracking it will trail it somewhat.
- Rising instalments. Many people raise their monthly amount as their salary grows. That puts more money in later, so the result leans more on recent years.
How we measured
- Data: daily KSE-100 closes stored by Capitalist, 2 January 2013 to 6 November 2026.
- Instalments: Rs10,000 at the close of the first trading day of each month, in fractional units of the index.
- Yearly rate: the internal rate of return (XIRR) of the monthly payments against the final value.
- Index basis: PSX describes the KSE-100 as a total return index in its PSX's KSE-100 index brochure.
Past results do not predict future returns. This article is general information, not investment advice.
Last reviewed